Last Updated on 45 minutes ago by Aayushman Vishwanathan
Three years ago, a Pat Cummins-led Australia pulled off an incredible victory at the Narendra Modi Stadium in Ahmedabad against India to seal their sixth 50-over World Cup title.
The undefeated India were heavy favourites heading into the title clash even against serial winners Australia. But the result from what transpired 20 years ago in Johannesburg hadn’t changed. If anything, Cummins had eclipsed what Ricky Ponting had achieved by methodically captaining Australia to victory over a seemingly invincible Indian side.
Cummins achieved what he aspired 24 hours before the final, which was to silence the enormous crowd. But fast forward three years later, his captaincy tenure stands on the brink of an ill-fated exit.
Cameron Bancroft’s testimonial makes the situation all the more uncomfortable for Pat Cummins
Former teammate Cameron Bancroft’s 4500-word testimonial of what happened in Cape Town in 2018 has blown the situation wide open. The story vindicates the accounts from Usman Khawaja, David Warner and Chadd Sayers, who claimed the entire team knew.
It puts Cummins’ 70-minute press conference firmly in the spotlight. He made it clear he won’t answer any further questions about sandpapergate, but that would be next to impossible given Bancroft’s bombshell.
And Cummins is losing public support. In a poll conducted by CODE Sports, 82% of the 13,000 voters believe Bancroft and Khawaja over Cummins.
Published first in the West Australian, Bancroft’s column is a raw and unfiltered version of the Gqeberha and Cape Town events; a seemingly more reliable account than Cummins’ presser. Although the Australian Test captain fronted up and answered the questions with aplomb, it looks he may have gambled the wrong card, given Bancroft has named names and the accuracy of the events is as compelling as any.
And there is the question of then Cricket Australia Media Manager Kate Hutchison. Bancroft revealed Hutchison said their ball-tampering plans were wrong and warned him of the consequences. If she knew, it begs the question – how could Cummins not?
What about the legacy of the bowling cartel?
While Josh Hazlewood and Nathan Lyon are yet to break their silence after vehemently denying knowing about sandpaper in their 2021 statement, Cummins and Starc maintained consistency from that statement.
The bowling cartel’s legacy may well have an asterisk attached to them moving forward and its Cummins whose reputation is firmly on the line, as is his future as captain. The 33-year-old may not have a lot of playing years left and is also under pressure to rediscover his form after a tough series in South Africa.
Cummins’ own marathon briefing may have cornered him, evident by his manager continuing to issue statements denying knowledge of sandpaper on the pacer’s behalf. But the media fraternity’s sustained pressure means the truth will come out sooner or later.
Cricket Australia messed things up from the start
That brings us to Cricket Australia’s botched investigation eight years ago. Along with Bancroft, Khawaja claiming he wasn’t interviewed, Warner’s accusation of a cover-up, and Sayers’ recollection of his role on the boundary reeks of a board that didn’t take the necessary steps to uncover the full truth.
Accepting collective responsibility back in 2018 would have buried this episode long ago. Instead, sandpapergate is still dominating the headlines today.
Bancroft’s revelations has rendered the “independent forum” futile. The situation has reached the extent that Cricket Australia must launch another investigation to find out the truth.
While Cummins faces accusation of ‘lying through his teeth’, could he and the bowling cartel be blamed? Was he under pressure from Cricket Australia to keep denying his involvement?
Under Cricket Australia’s contract, players are prohibited from making defamatory statements against stakeholders or disclosing confidential information. However, the media will hang in there and dig deeper for the definitive truth, and who knows how much longer Cummins can withstand it.
Is there a case for Steve Smith to return as Australia’s Test captain?
While Cummins has, on occasions, hinted he may not want to captain until the end of the playing career, there’s a chance his reign has a premature end before the New Zealand series.
Whether or not Cummins and the cartel retain their spots or make it to the next Ashes will depend on how Cricket Australia navigates the process.
But is there a case for Steve Smith to return as Test captain? Smith could be the right man to navigate the ship through this storm given his tactical acumen and how he decided to own the mistake in South Africa immediately instead of delaying it.
Smith should have certainly been stronger to stop the wrongdoing but remains wise after years of copping flak from fans and ex-cricketers. Even if the superstar Test batter returns as skipper, it would have to be a stopgap option, given the age and willingness to continue playing, especially now that the scandal has resurfaced.
Smith is on record saying his Test future is a series-by-series proposition, keeping Australian cricket on their toes.
Australia will no doubt need Smith’s nous not only heading into massive tours of India and England but also nurturing the next generation. Should Cummins voluntarily step down and Smith deny a full-time role, the successor may well need both to ensure a serviceable transition.
Bancroft claims that revealing his version of events unfiltered has ‘freed’ him. His healing process has begun. However, Australian cricket has still a way to go to reach theirs.
There is every chance that this ugly episode is just getting started.
The views expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of CricBlog.

