Last Updated on 1 second ago by Charbel Coorey
Pat Cummins is facing increased scrutiny following Cameron Bancroft’s bombshell 4,500-word article on sandpapergate earlier this week. Cummins’ manager, Neil Maxwell, has called for calm and an end to the “hysteria” around the captain and whether he should remain in the role.
Bancroft wrote that Cummins’ marathon 68-minute press conference on November 13 prompted him to publish his account of what took place in 2018. The former Test opener is adamant everyone knew – including then-Media Manager Kate Hutchison – revealing he had regular conversations with the bowlers on the field regarding reverse swing.
However, Maxwell insists that Cummins’ media conference answers all of Bancroft’s claims. He says:
- Cummins was not an architect of any ball-tampering claims and was unaware that sandpaper was taken onto the field at any stage.
- The banned trio of Steve Smith, David Warner and Cameron Bancroft were treated unfairly by Cricket Australia (CA).
Pat Cummins under the microscope: Manager Neil Maxwell calls for end to “hysteria” after Cameron Bancroft article in The West Australian
Maxwell reiterated Cummins’ stance, while sharing his sympathy with the players who were suspended for an extended period of time across 2018 and 2019.
“There is currently a hysteria unfounded in reality. When you go through it all calmly and in detail, Pat’s eight-year long position and 68-minute Q and A stands up,” Maxwell said in a statement, as quoted by CODE Sports.
“There is no serious case he was an architect of ball tampering or knew sandpaper was going on the field.
“It’s also true that the players who were suspended paid far too high a price. Year-long bans for ball tampering (compared to what) players in other countries did and were suspended for just a few games. They have always been right to feel aggrieved by that.”
Question marks around Pat Cummins’ status as Australia captain
Sandpapergate has reared its ugly head in recent weeks following Usman Khawaja’s revelations two weeks ago, that have since been supported by Bancroft, Warner and Chadd Sayers. Some pundits, former players and fans have called for Cummins to resign as captain as they believe he’s part of the cover-up.
“Cummins is in trouble. Two more players involved in the South Africa tour, Bancroft and Chadd Sayers, Australia’s 12th man at the Port Elizabeth Test in 2018, have come forward to say that Cummins’ version of events is false,” wrote Oliver Holt in the Daily Mail.
Piers Morgan supports this statement, asking “three of the team say they all knew; are we really supposed to believe that the rest of the team are now going to pretend they didn’t?”
Former Australia fast bowler Mitchell Johnson says there is no way back for Cummins. “I think he will still try to stand by what he has said and his statement with all of the bowlers back in 2021,” Johnson wrote in his piece for The West Australian.
“But I think the public pressure for Cummins to stand down as Test captain now will be too much.
“I just can’t see how his captaincy and personal brand survives this.”
Manager reminds fans of the role Cummins has played over the past eight years
Amid the chaos, Maxwell has called for critics to remember the contribution Cummins has made since 2018. By Cummins’ own admission, the Australian team had an “ugly underbelly” which he has worked hard to fix as captain.
“Pat’s position hasn’t changed in eight years. He’s been consistent and adamant from day one,” said Maxwell.
“Pat feels for Cam of course. He has been through a lot. We would urge people to again read Pat’s interview transcript. There is nothing he hasn’t answered. And that includes in response to what Cam has now said.
“Pat has rebuilt the Australian cricket team. That 24-year-old in Cape Town resolved to fix the team and spent eight years doing it.”

